Be sure to read “Part I: Trick or Treat?” so you know what the heck is going on.

Jane and I enter the big room and there is only one other couple in there – they are fucking on the bed across from us. We drop our towels and start getting things warmed up.

I am focusing on Jane tonight – she’s going to have a good time, damn it.

Soon enough, Sally enters with … The Cap’n?

No complaints from Jane on Sally’s choice of partner, that’s for sure.

He is wearing his awesome pirate hat (at the request of Sally). They lie down next to us and start kissing. Soon after, things start getting heated.

Jane and I are 69ing at first but then shift around to pay some attention to our friends. Sally mentions that she needs to pay back Jane for not reciprocating during our last encounter and The Cap’n is very into my blushing bride.

They both lay Jane down and Sally starts tonguing her.

“It is so hot watching you getting your pussy licked by her!” I whisper into Jane’s ear.

“She’s not very good,” Jane says under her breath, so only I can hear.

I am playing with Jane’s tits and kissing her while Sally is playing with her naughty bits. The Cap’n joins her and soon enough, Sally yields Jane’s pussy to her superior officer.

“You’ll probably do a much better job than me,” she says, moving aside.

I don’t think Jane is going to object after that half-hearted effort…

He dives in and does his thing and Jane starts moaning soon after. While I am I’m sucking Jane’s tits and talking dirty to her, I suddenly feel a mouth on my cock and really, really hope that it’s Sally.

Thank God.

In spite of the fact that I am totally mentally into this, I am still very focused on Jane as The Cap’n brings her to another orgasm. She looks so beautiful when she cums and The Cap’n comments on that same fact.

Several times.

“You could squirt if you try,” he tells Jane, “You just have to let go! Just relax and let it go. You can do it! You like that, don’t you…”

I smile inside. My wife is so beautiful and really enjoying the attention from everyone. Yay!

“Does she cum a lot?” asks Sally about Jane as she has her third or fourth screaming orgasm in the last ten minutes.

“Yeah, I usually lose count,” is my reply.

The scene is rapidly descending into an informal orgy as two more couples come into the room and lay down next to the four of us. I force myself to concentrate and not watch anyone else – we know where that leads…

I think this is my issue with public sex as opposed to just simple group sex in a private setting. Like I have mentioned, I don’t particularly like being exposed and naked around a bunch of other people when anyone can walk in at anytime.

I feel vulnerable and that’s not exactly confidence-inspiring. To me, sex is a very private act and I am always paranoid about getting “surprised” when I’m vulnerable.

An actual conversation I had with myself at this moment:

“Not again! Why in the hell did I come to another orgy?”

“Because it’s an orgy, stupid.”

“Oh, yeah.”

It’s the unpredictable nature of this room that causes me to ride a roller coaster of hard-soft-hard-soft-hard over the next 20 minutes as The Cap’n and I rotate partners. He is also having some performance issues - mostly related to wearing a condom. This is a shame because Jane really wants to fuck him.

She recounted after the fact that “I got him nice and hard when I was sucking his dick, but it was like that condom was kryptonite…”

I can definitely sympathize, but say nothing. No guy wants to hear “It happens, bro” from another guy. It’s bad enough coming from a girl, but you definitely don’t want to hear that from a dude. He continues trying to pleasure the girls orally and manually and is clearly having a really good time, in spite of his problem.

Jane mentions later that he told her he usually has to take a half Viagra to keep things moving with a condom on. He also tells her that he is 47 years old.

And I thought Sally made me feel old.

I am able to keep focused as Jane joins me again.

“I want to fuck,” she states matter-of-factly.

She has managed to keep me at attention, so I gladly roll her over and slide into that sweet pussy, sans condom.

She is my wife, after all.

While I’m fucking Jane, there is a pile of bodies next to us, writhing and moaning. Jane and Sally start making out while I’m fucking her and Sally starts playing with Jane’s boobs. I grab Sally’s hand and place it on Jane’s pussy while I am sliding my cock in. Sally rubs around on Jane’s clit and pretty soon, she’s having another orgasm.

The Cap’n starts playing with Jane’s tits, kissing her and talking dirty, Sally is still rubbing Jane’s clit and I am pounding her as hard and fast as I can.

It’s no wonder Jane has another earthshaking orgasm a few seconds later.

Then Sally (it better have been Sally – I never did see who it was) starts tickling my balls from behind while I’m fucking Jane, tracing my testicles and perineum with her nails.

Oh my.

That’s why I go to orgies!

During this activity, I get about as close to my own orgasm as I will get tonight. At least at the club. It’s too bad she only did it for about 10 seconds or I would have.

Jane is the focus and she is going to be the center of attention tonight. This is what it’s all about: Fucking my wife while another chick plays with both of us.

Selfish? Yes.

The truth? Yes.

Jane and I stop fucking and she moves over to help Sally try to get things moving with The Cap’n. Sally climbs on top of him and starts shaking her tits in his face and kissing him while Jane sucks his dick. I am fingering Jane from behind while she sucks him. I reach over and start fingering Sally from behind while she straddles The Cap’n on all fours.

My hand is literally inches away from touching his cock. I have never touched another man’s penis and don’t particularly want to start tonight.

I am extra careful not to get too close, but Sally is plainly enjoying this, so I stick another finger in and start trying to hit her G-spot. I have two fingers in each girl and both are pushing back on my hands with each simultaneous thrust now.

Yeah, this is going in the blog…

They are unable to make any progress with him and I manage to avoid any incidental contact with another man’s genitals.

Jane tells me she wants to fuck me some more, since nothing was happenin’ with The Cap’n.

Shortly after this, Jane and I are fucking and we look up and one of the other girls has stolen The Cap’n’s hat and is showing it off while fucking her husband. He asks for it back and she taunts him. “You’re gonna have to come and get it…” she says, invitingly.

The Cap’n moves over to wrest his hat away from the thieving wench while she bounces up and down on her man’s dick. I lose track of the scene after that, trying mostly to focus on fucking Jane. After a bit, The Cap’n starts playing with the hat thief and her man moves over to join Sally.

He and Sally mess around for a bit and then Sally – apparently resigned to the fact that I am occupied with Jane – starts fucking him.

I certainly wanted (and planned) to fuck Sally tonight, but the world is not going to end if I don’t. It’s clear what her intentions are, since I was obviously going to be able to perform much better than I did during our first meeting. But her petulant behavior when I was not paying attention to her kind of turned me off and I honestly wasn’t that disappointed that nothing happened between us.

I think she thinks I’m a little more into her than I really am.

Oh well.

Tonight is about Jane and she is feeling good about herself (for a change). She was the center of attention and I’m so happy she felt so sexy and wanted.

Not to mention having about ten orgasms!

We finish up fucking and, since everyone who is able already has a partner, we decide to head downstairs. We’re not going to get kicked out of here at 3am again.

We are disheveled and sweaty as we make our way to the car, but still energized and really, really hungry. We run through a late-night drive thru and grab some chow.

After we finish eating, I let our food settle and then set to trying to get Jane to have sex with me again. Jane, ever the trooper, gives it up to me with a healthy dose of Astroglide.

I get my orgasm at last, not even caring if Jane gets yet another one…

Selfish prick, aren’t I?

Next: Date With a Unicorn